Retrieved
From:
https://kenanmalik.wordpress.com/2012/03/04/why-both-sides-are-wrong-in-the-race-debate/
As human beings we
are always trying to group things and individuals to get a better understanding
and race just happen to be one of those things. Race is ultimately a social
construct, which means that the idea of race and classification of humans by
race is not biologically based. It is a particular way of viewing one another
which stems from colonial encounterment and trying to make sense of something
that was unfamiliar. The earliest classification based on race as we know comes
from Linnaeus' taxonomy to group people who share similar physical and cultural
traits. In the film “Race: The Power of an Illusion, Episode 1,” Pilar
Ossorio, a microbiologist stated that “There’s as much or more diversity and
genetic difference within any racial group as there is between people of
different racial groups.” As a scientific concept Ossorio's statement bears
weight because it was scientifically proven within the film that those
classified as the same race were ore different than those
who weren't same race. Ultimately this means that a black person and
a white person can be genetically more similar to one another as oppose to two
people who are black. Showing us that there is nothing embedded within our DNA
that determines what race we will be. Therefore classification of race based on
biology is a very
"flawed" system since
there isn't any special gene located within the DNA that
determines race. According to Philip N. Cohen, genetics does not
explain the relative status and well-being of today’s racially identified
groups or their broader societies in fact race is used a mean of social
inequality. Typically, when
I think of myself racially I identify as a black woman. I believe that on a
phenotypical level looking at my facial features can also allow others to
categorize me as such. The texture of my hair, the shape and size of my eyes,
nose, lips and etc. are all phenotypical features that will lead someone to the
conclusion that I am black. Apart from all of these being physical features
which relates to phenotype and the “scientific” aspect, sociologically speaking
these same features will lead someone to simply be capable of determining my
race based on how society has classified features of individuals. But there
isn't any specific gene within my DNA that would point out that i am black.
With that being said just because there isn't a "precise
demarcation" in terms of genes that labels us in our DNA there
are features that labels us in society. Despite how hard we may try to break away
from race because there isn't any scientific gene that makes one
race superior to another, socially the dominant group views of race
in general seems unchanging.
Photo Credit: http://www.crystalinks.com/faces.html
Refrences
Cohen, P. N. (2015). How troubling is our inheritance? A review of genetics and race in the social sciences. Annals Of The American Academy Of Political And Social Science, 661(1), 65-84. doi:10.1177/0002716215587673
Golash-Boza, Tanya Maria. (2015). Race & racisms : a critical approach. New York :Oxford University Press,
Hochschild, J., & Sen, M. (2015). Genetic determinism, technology optimism, and race: Views of the American public. Annals Of The American Academy Of Political And Social Science, 661(1), 160-180. doi:10.1177/0002716215587875
Hey , I enjoyed your reading. I like the way you gave us a historic timetable of the concept of race. Your paper reflects how you focused and presented the scientific aspect of race very well. However I would suggest editing the first and last sentence of the paper for grammatical errors including indenting the second paragraph. I also believe you should talk about how race is a sociological concept and how its still relevant during our times(education, etc) . I also did not see the two links that were required. Overall I enjoyed your reading and your point of view.
ReplyDeleteI did include the 2 links. They appeared grey which blended with the text hence why it wasn't obvious
DeleteI think you've done a great job of explaining how race is not biological concept. It was very well written and easy to understand, what I would suggest is bringing in the ideas of it being sociological. You mention it briefly but it would be nice to see the balance between the two. I think everything else is done well. Good job!
ReplyDelete