Wednesday, September 21, 2016

Hijacking Identities


Kevin Howard


Race associatively could be thought of as division. Historically that is exactly what it has done. Specifically, in the Americas and more uniquely in the U.S. Race has become an institution on its own and its maintenance is a continuous working project. Ossorio takes into account the different societal elements that have fostered race and nurture it. Within the first episode of Race: The power of Illusion Ossorio explains that this divide, this supposed difference between “groups” of people is nothing more than an orchestrated fallacy. Imposed on society specifically in the U.S to create inorganic divisions between people. As evidence to her claim, Ossorio turns to the use of genetics as a tool to scientifically prove that people have little difference between each other. Her use of genetics comes to lessen the biological gap created during the 19th and 20th century when common belief was certain groups of people were essentially different and therefore placed them hierarchically in respect to other groups of people. Genetics can and has given the physical proof that as a species humans share a similar biological foundation that links them together. Surface variations are nothing more than environmental subjections.

            Personally race has been a very obscure subject. It has never been much of importance to me. Having to define myself has rarely fallen on a racial identification but much rather metaphysical aspects of myself that presumably mean more to people. Among a certain group of people there is the very common question of “what are you” which has been sarcastically answered with “I’m human” but has that been ignorance or just the rejection of placing myself into a category or a square it is not so clear. When forced and in many instances it has been, I am categorized as racially mixed, being Central American and Irish it would seem fitting and yet there are some who see me being either or and not the two put together. On school and government forms other or mixed is usually the box checked off. If next to that other or mixed box there is an underlined free space to explain then that liberty is taken, making the reason for checking “other” more clear. Personally race is not really a part of my identity because I am mixed, two cultures, two languages and two origins it isn’t so easy to say your one without the other for me. For most of my life I’ve laid more claim to nationalistic categories than racial ones.

            After the documentary the concept of race expanded to mean the culmination of beliefs around difference. That being said would following a “racial logic” make sense anymore? If science has proven to us that race is in fact an “illusion” then would my identifying with a race not make my entire identity in itself an illusion? Ossorio’s work has granted me the power to concretize my identity beyond race.   

http://www.pbs.org/show/black-in-latin-america/

http://www.npr.org/2012/07/07/156306806/super-mario-challenges-the-idea-of-whos-an-italian
http://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2013/08/13/211336128/italys-first-black-minister-finds-herself-a-target-of-slurs

2 comments:

  1. Kevin, I loved this piece! The way you articulated, formed and organized your ideas left me totally understanding your viewpoint on race and your own identity. You did an excellent job answering all components of the initial questions. However you are missing some key requirements that would enhance this unique piece. When working on your revision:
    1) Add two copyright permissible images
    2) Include two external websites in your piece.For example when you mention Ossorio you can include a hyper link to the film.
    3)You need to include two outside academic sources. The articles you listed are great, however they are not academic sources. Also the articles you citied are not mentioned at all in your piece. Academic scholarly support would greatly enhance your blog post! Your piece was clearly written, properly formed paragraphs,and grammar is good!
    Good luck with the revision and I look forward to reading your revised piece!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Kevin,
    While reading your blogpost, I was looking to see if you accomplished all the assignment requirements. Based on this, I noted that your blog post does include a title and two links. However, your blog post lacks two copyright permissible images and two outside academic sources. In order to find good academic sources, you can use the CCNY library website. Click on "find articles and journals" and then click on "academic search complete". Also, you will need to put these sources in APA format. For this, you can use bibme.org. It will generate a citation for you. Aside from this, your blog post was extremely well written. I really liked the language and vocabulary you used. The paragraphs were also properly formed.
    Lastly, I will note that you answered all the questions needed for this assignment. You provided evidence for Pilar Ossorio's statement, you stated the relationship between the sociological and scientific concept of race and you identified your thought on your race and race in general.
    Great Work,
    Ingrid

    ReplyDelete