Lena McKnight 9/21/2016 Racial Identity
Photo By: Sarah Leen
Race has been used for years to place
people into different social constructs in society. Scientist studied the idea
of race, to attempt to show how a particular group of people can achieve more
than another set of people based on elements that are influenced by racial
identity. Census has shown that people are identifying themselves beyond the
four categories originally set in place by scientist. When one considers race
from a sociological standpoint we can see evidence that shows that the original
concept of race is wrong. It is impossible to classify all people into four
simple categories because DNA shows us that its much more complex than what
meets the eye. For example, people may identify themselves to be African
American however they could possess the same mitochondrial DNA as people who
identifies themselves as Asian.
Ossorio shows how complex race is as
he offers suggestions that scientist is wrong to use it to determine personal
external and internal differences. The idea of race according to Ossoriso came
from scientist who believed that you can define race into four classifications,
but according to the relationship of what race means to a person can change on
an individual base. The film “Race: The Power of Illusion, Episode 1”, Pillar
Ossorio, students were asked to give a sample of their DNA, to test with other with
other students to see which modern genetics match. Students believed the
fallacies that they would have more similarity with the same person from the
racial back ground based on physical features. The study showed that many of
their mitochondrial DNA was similar to students who were different racial
categories thus proving that physical features alone cannot determine a person’s
racial identity.
The
idea of a person identifying themselves according to one of the four races
classifications that scientist thought a person could identify with has
changed. Grieco, showed how individuals labels themselves as more than one
classification according to the census. Grieco gave an example from the census
2000 on how the categories were split giving more people options to choose
their racial background. From the 1990 census they showed that standard outline
in the OMB has changed for the 2000 census. The categories have changed by
splitting Asian and Pacific Islander thus creating five categories and giving
people the option of choosing more than one racial identification. This alone
shows that a person identification may change over time.
When considering race, I think, how
can I label myself to one particular group? Although when applying for a job I put
African American, my parents’ ancestors are a collection of different origins
and racial classifications. I like to consider myself as a person raised in New
York with southern roots. Thus when asked about my race I tend to consider myself
as southern. My mother’s parents are southern German, Blackfoot Indian, and
Creole and my father’s parents are of African descent from the south. Once a
year to stay connected we all come together for family gatherings. This helps
to keep us stay connected to our roots and to understand our family background.
References
Glasgow, M. J. (2003). On The New Biology of Race. Journal of
Philosophy, Inc., 456-474.
Grieco,
M. E. (2002). An Evaluation of Bridging
Methods Using Race Data from Census 2000. Springer in cooperation with the
Southern Demographic Association, 91-107.
Hi Lena,
ReplyDeleteOverall, this is good piece. Maybe you could go more in depth about your racial identity. Possibly explain more why you chose the term "Southern." When I first read it, I thought you meant southern states. As I kept reading, I realized that that may not have been what you meant.
I noticed that you did not provide proper in-text citation when you referred to your articles. Take a look at the "written work guideline" that the professor provided for us on blackboard. Also, you did not provide the two URL links, these can be a youtube video or a non scholarly article. In addition, the professor required two images, do not forget to add your second image. I love the one you provided by the way.
Hope my feedback is of great help. Good Luck!
I loved your opening sentence I do agree with that and history has shown it. I agree with you and the census point I prefer being specific instead of being put in the genre category. If your going to mention and author or writer use the APA format to give credit and cite properly. You need another picture and two additional resources. I see a slight reputation when talking bout the DNA and being closer just jump right into that in the ending of your first paragraph and beginning of second. So cool that you know deeper into your race remember to include that with how does all that we learn change your perspective a little bit more or how it doesn't. I agree how can I be under one group when we are all mixed in some way. Try transitioning better so it can flow more and I love that your connected to your family in the south. I'm half black I have family from South Carolina but never been would love to go. Good job and good luck.
ReplyDelete