Ingrid Diaz
Sociology 25300
Professor: Dr. R. L’Heureux Lewis-McCoy
Due Date: September 21, 2016
The
Misinterpretations of Race.
Race
is defined as a group of individuals that share supposed physical and/or
genetic traits. The sociological concept of race suggests that we are
socialized to differentiate individuals by their physical/external attributes.
We are brought up to believe that we can identify another individual’s race
just by looking at them. We divide individuals into categories of race based on
the color of their skin, the texture of their hair, and the shape/color of
their eyes. Because we are socialized to accept and integrate the concept of
race into our lives, we try to attribute these physical/external differences to
internal differences. The scientific concept of race suggests that these
external attributes must derive from some sort of genetic similarity. However, as Pilar Ossorio states, there is
just as much or more genetic difference between individuals within the same
racial group as there is between different racial groups. This statement has
been proven by biologists and geneticists. The physical traits that we adapt
through environmental differences do not reflect genetic differentiation
(Templeton, 2013).
According
to the United States Census Bureau, there are five races in which an individual
can identify with (http://www.census.gov/topics/population/race/about.html). These races
include White, Black/African American, Asian, Native Hawaiian/Other Pacific
Islander and Other. An individual can mark more than one box in this section of
the census. This makes it difficult for me to choose a race when filling out
forms because I do not identify myself with any of these races. I consider
myself Hispanic and not any of the previously mentioned races. However,
according to the United States Census Bureau, Hispanic and Latina are not
considered a race instead they are considered an ethnicity. Ethnicity is
defined as belonging to a social group that has similar cultural backgrounds.
Therefore, when I have to choose a race when filling out forms I usually choose
white. This is a problem because in social context I do not identify as being
part of the white race.
Noticeably, this
is not just a problem that I encounter but a problem that many of Hispanics and
Latino ethnic background have when filling out forms and I am one of many
individuals of Hispanic and Latino background that are identifying themselves
as white. According to a New York Times article, researchers found that out of
the 35 million Americans in the United States that identify themselves as
Hispanic, approximately 2.5 million of them choose “Some Oher Race” in the 2000
census and changed their race to “White” in the 2010 census (http://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/22/upshot/more-hispanics-declaring-themselves-white.html?_r=0). This research
suggests that in fact choosing a race can be very confusing for Hispanics
because the options provided are not relevant enough. According to a Pew
Research Center survey, two-thirds of Hispanics labeled their Hispanic
background as part of their race (Gonzales-Barrera & Lopez, 2015). The
problem with this is that Hispanics are the largest growing ethnic and racial
group in the United States and by 2060 we will make up approximately 29% of the
population.
Works Cited
Gonzalez-Barrera, A., & Lopez, M. H.
(2015). Is Being Hispanic a Matter of Race, Ethnicity or Both?
Templeton, A. R. (2013). Biological races
in humans. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in
History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 44(3), 262-271.
doi:10.1016/j.shpsc.2013.04.010
Hi Ingrid!
ReplyDeleteGreat work! I feel your piece was very well written. I could clearly see you answered all aspects of the initial question. I understand your explanation from both a sociological and scientific aspect. Your title was unique and you included two permissible images. Just don't forget to attribute where you got the images from in the captions section.
You are missing one academic source. The article about being Hispanic as a race, ethnicity or both, I dont believe is a academic source. If Im wrong, my apoligies, but I would double check with Professor.You did an excellent job using your articles to support your ideas. Grammar and language is good, and your paragraohs are properly formatted!
Minor revisions!
Ingrid,
ReplyDeleteTo begin your comment instantly jumps into the academic conception of race and how it has been defined in differing disciplines which is solid for a bases. Your personal experience with race is revealing of the trouble not only individuals have with race but entire groups, from what you suggest. Yet at this point I'd want to highlight that although your suggestions are backed with statistics gather by the census, the numbers are not as staggering as one would imagine. 2.5 Million out of 35 million is a really small percentage compared to the total of Latinos that do identify as Latino/a. Simply put the majority of people with origins in Spanish speaking countries do check off Latino/a and the really question is why 2.5 million people check off other? Secondly if you do not identify with any race then why chose to check off white on government forms, (this is not a direct judgement but a question and curiosity), why not chose "other" and explain yourself, and when you say that government forms do not recognize Latino/a as a race, government forms provide a "Hispanic (non-white) category? Beside my curiosities, your post does meet all criteria expected by the professor, although you make no reference to what your point of view was after having seen the documentary which is apart of the question.
All in all, the post was well composed I'd just add that last bit of your point of view after seeing the documentary and also take into consideration my questions.
K.Howard