Baghdad
Morshed
Sept 16, 2016.
Sept 16, 2016.
The Conceptualization of Race
Throughout history race is conceptualized
to categorize people based on their physical appearance. Michael Banton (1989) explains
in his book, Racial Theories, that race
is no longer a “phenotype” which a means physical characteristic. When we use
the word race we are more likely to think about the folk concept of the word. According
to Banton, the folk definition of race is the social formation that is created
based on everyday experience. The definition of such a word is no longer based
on its real meanings; in fact the concept is based on what the old scientific
theories, media, and history had created. While many scientific evidences proved
that people have diverse genetic makeup even among those who share the same
skin color. The racial formation of race as folk concept enhanced the idea that
one’s visual appearance can explain the outcomes or the behaviors of the
collectivist group that the person belongs to (Omi 2008).
First, the folk concept of
race was first created by some racist scientific Europeans, who argued
that people are genetically different from one another and used this
explanation to group those who share the same ethnicity to place them at one
level of the racial hierarchy. For example, the German Nazi categorized Jews as
biologically inferior to those who have pure German descent (Banton 1989). What
the German scientists ignored that sharing same religion does not mean sharing
the same genes.
Race continues to
reform around scientific theories that creates stereotypes. Racist ideologies
used science to support certain claims to categorize individual based on what
they call “genetic make.”Although it may seem that individuals with similar skin
color share the same genes, the skin color genes have many versions. The
diversity of the skin color gene results in diversely in skin color; there are
people with different degrees of lightness and darkness. For instance, I am a
Middle Eastern, and I am considered to be “White,” my skin color is not white,
and I do not feel that this is the right category for me. This makes skin color
not a reliable characteristic to group people. Therefore, using skin color to
classify people is a silly as saying lets using fingerprints to group people.
An image of German anthropology that is measuring a woman’s features to know whether her racial ancestry is Jewish or pure German. By: The United States Holocaust Memorial |
A picture that was taken by Castile's girlfriend on her camera phone after the police shot her boyfriend. By: The Daily Mirror newspaper |
Allen, N., Rouge, B. (2016,
July 7). Fatal Shooting Of Black Man Philando Castile By Police
During Traffic Stop In Minneapolis Caught on Video By Girlfriend. The Telegraph News. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/07/07/fatal-shooting-of-black-man-by-police-during-traffic-stop-in-min/
Banton,
M. P. (1998). Racial Theories.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
1-12.
Jewkes,
Y. (2014). Punishment in Black and White: Penal “Hell-Holes,” Popular Media,
and
Mass Incarceration. Atlantic Journal Of Communication, 22(1), 42-60.
Omi, M.,Winant, H. (2008). Racial Formation,
Understanding Race and Racism in the Post Civil
Rights Era. The Social Issues Collection. 1-99.
This is very well planned and thought out. it flows well and is very well spoken, however, you don't really talk too much about Pilar Ossorio or his quote that we were supposed to build off of. You also don't have the two links the professor Asked for. Otherwise, good job.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHi Baghdad,
ReplyDeleteHere are some comments to make your post stronger:
Overall, you made use of your two external websites and articles and completed the requirements. However, to answer the prompt I would have liked you to reference the documentary.Also, by referencing the documentary, I think it would have helped you to connect all of you cited material, and state the relationship between the sociological and biological constructions of race better. When you used your source about the “folk concept,” I think it’s best to put it in quotation marks since it is someone else’s concept, and you’re defining it for us. Other than that, just check your post for grammar issues. Your post was well written and well thought-out.
All the best!
-Minah